Drinking Out: The Louisville Cathouse at Clover Club

After the holidays, after a couple weeks of frantic catching up at work and then a hasty weekend trip for wedding, followed by more feverish catching up at work, I finally had time to go out for a drink.

Clover Club in Brooklyn’s Carroll Gardens neighborhood has become my default bar for a good and relaxing cocktail for a number of reasons. First, the drinks are almost always excellent and inventive (with plenty of classics on the list, too). The space is large and comfortable and the happy hour (5-7pm) is fantastic: $6 for a rotating list of classic drinks like the Jack Rose.

But when I got to the bar yesterday, I couldn’t resist ordering from the regular menu. The Louisville Cathouse ($11) is ancho chili-infused bourbon, crème de cacao and Fernet Branca, served in a frosty metal julep cup with pebbled ice and a mint sprig. While it doesn’t exactly sound like a winter drink, the mild but persistent heat and sweet earthy flavor of the peppers was refreshing on a rainy New York evening.

I guess I could have done without the mint julep treatment for this drink—a simple lowball glass with couple of ice cubes would have been fine, maybe with lemon zest rubbed on the rim. But I liked it anyway. The ancho and the bourbon mix surprisingly well together (why not try something other than tequila for a spicy pepper infusion?) and the cacao and Fernet gave it some balance.

Speaking of balance, my girlfriend ordered a Jack Rose from the happy hour menu, and we were surprised to find it quite un-balanced. I’ve praised Clover Club’s Jack Roses before for their perfect blending of the applejack, lime juice, and grenadine, but this was so heavy on the grenadine that I wondered if the bartender reversed the measurements and put less lime in. It was all the more puzzling after a conversation with a Lani Kai bartender a month ago (Clover Club, Lani Kai, and Flatiron Lounge are all run by Julie Reiner), during which he praised Reiner’s efforts to ensure that a classic cocktail at one of her bars would taste as good—and consistently good—as it would at another. Such inconsistency within one of her bars was unexpected.

This entry was posted in Cocktails, Drinking Out and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Drinking Out: The Louisville Cathouse at Clover Club

  1. Julie Reiner says:

    While we strive for perfection; we do make mistakes on occasion. It is always our policy to replace a cocktail that a guest feels is not right, or just not for them. Feel free to ask for a do over next time! Cheers.

  2. Wow! Thanks for reading, Julie! Of course you’re right — we should have asked for a new drink. But I must say, it’s hard to find anything to complain about with any of your bars. I had a beet cocktail at Flatiron Lounge recently that was remarkable. And as I said in the post above, Clover Club remains my favorite cocktail bar in Brooklyn.

  3. ms. franky says:

    Hello Harry,

    I’m so glad you enjoyed the Cathouse! That cocktail was inspired by a trip i made to Louisville last November with some Bartender pals from across the country.

    Yes, there was definitely some deliberation about whether or not to serve that drink in a rocks glass over cubes, or, as it is in a julep cup over cobbled ice. In the end, i decided to go along with the majority (for a change :o). In the future, if you’d like the Cathouse sans julep treatment, just let us know – that won’t be a problem.

    Take care,

    franky marshall

  4. Thanks for reading, Franky! The next time I order the Cathouse, I’ll have to try it the other way.

    For everyone reading out there, Franky is also the creator of one of my favorite cocktails of last year, the Eleventh Hour (Reposado tequila, mezcal, aquavit, yellow Chartreuse, lime juice, and cane syrup).

  5. Randall Roberts says:

    Hi ms Franky and Julie,
    Any hints as to how you make the ancho infused bourbon? How long to you infuse, any prior prep to the ancho…
    Brilliant cocktail!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s