Are Bottled Cocktails Worth It?

I love the idea of bottled cocktails but the first time I saw one for sale, I thought it was too expensive to bother with. At $50 for 750ml, High West’s 36th Vote Barreled Manhattan is not an impulse buy. I started doing some quick mental math, figuring I’d be better off aging a batch of Manhattans myself.

And then a friend texted me a photo of a little bottled Saratoga cocktail. “Have you had this?” The Fluid Dynamics barrel-aged line of bottled cocktails from California’s Craft Distillers, the producers of Germain-Robin brandy, aren’t actually any less expensive than High West’s versions—they just offer smaller bottles. But that was all it took to take another look at my math. At $18 to $20 for a 200ml bottle, you get just over 6.5 ounces of cocktail, enough for two generous three-ounce pours. I compare this to going to a good cocktail bar here in NYC where I might pay $12 to $14 per cocktail, perhaps more for a barrel-aged cocktail. So that’s nine or ten bucks each for an excellent drink at home versus an average of $25, plus tip for a great drink out. Why not?

Bottled Saratoga

A couple weeks later, my friend brought over a bottled Saratoga to share. It was excellent, and it reminded me how delicious some of the Manhattan variations can be—the Saratoga is basically a Manhattan with both whiskey and brandy.

Craft Distillers uses Germain-Robin brandy (probably their $50 Craft-Method brandy), Low Gap clear wheat whiskey, and Quady Winery’s Vya sweet vermouth. Notably absent is the bitters. Craft Distillers’ press materials say, “We did not include bitters because they become overpowering in the barrel.” We’re instructed to add a dash ourselves; I didn’t, and it was fantastic anyway: velvety and viscous, very harmonious and a great blending of the brandy’s sweet vanilla notes with the whiskey’s more assertive spice. It’s kind of funny that they use an un-aged whiskey, and then age the whole mixture. It works well.

Bottled Saratoga sideview

Craft Distillers is vague about how long each of the Fluid Dynamics cocktails are aged. The site says “the recipes take months to develop,” but I read that as the creative process, not the aging process. Clearly, it can’t take too long to age or it wouldn’t be worth the trouble. When I’ve aged cocktails myself (I’ve done an apple brandy Old Fashioned and a Negroni), the sweet spot was about 6 weeks for my little one-liter barrel. We also don’t know what size barrels are used here.

The other cocktails in the Fluid Dynamics series are a Brandy Manhattan, The 1850 (a Sazerac variation with brandy and whiskey, plus a bit of the Germain-Robin absinthe), and the St. Nick (brandy with Clear Creek distillery’s Cranberry liqueur). All, including the Saratoga, end up at 32.7% abv. Liter-sized bottles of the cocktails are available, but apparently only for bars.

These bottled cocktails aren’t new, but this is the first time I’ve seen them in New York. David Driscoll at K&L Wines in California introduced them to his customers back in October 2011 and he came to much the same conclusions I did — and the Saratoga was his favorite.

Now, looking back, I’m almost ready to shell out $50 for a High West Barreled Manhattan: that’s eight 3-ounce cocktails at about $6 each, with some left over.

This entry was posted in Cocktails and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Are Bottled Cocktails Worth It?

  1. I’ve been curious about these, so I suppose I should take the plunge and try them now. A couple places in Mpls carry the 1L bottles which seem like a good option for a party. Did you dilute these or are they pre-diluted?

    Regarding the High West, I personally like the Manhattan better than the Boulevardier, but they are both worth trying (I also haven’t had the Manhattan for a couple years so YMMV). The Boulevardier is a bit different in that they use Gran Classico in place of Campari which gives it a lighter more grapefruity flavor. It’s great to keep in the fridge and pour over one big ice cube.

    • I measured out three ounces and poured it over ice in a mixing glass to cool and dilute. At the time I had just assumed they had already added the bitters. I strained them into cocktail glasses and drank without ice. I really liked it and so did the friend who brought the bottle over.

      I’ll have to fit the High West version into my budget this summer, especially after your endorsement.

      Speaking of keeping cocktails in the fridge, I don’t know why I don’t make a big batch of, say, Negronis, and keep them in the fridge for a quick, cool cocktail in the summer. I need to consult my friend Kara Newman’s Cocktails for a Crowd book again for ideas.

  2. Pingback: Linkage | Uncouth Reflections

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s